Connect with us

Technology

‘Google,’ ‘University of Chicago’ Faces Class Action Over ‘Electronic Health Record’ Breach

Google and the University of Chicago Medical Center are facing a class action lawsuit for sharing electronic health records with each other without consent.

Published

on

Google and UCMC partnered to create an AI for medical use but they are now facing raps for it. Photo: Inventorchris | Flickr | CC BY 2.0

San Francisco-based tech giant, Google, is once again in the center of a class action lawsuit together with the University of Chicago Medical Center with what is likely “the greatest heist of consumer medical records in history.”

The class-action lawsuit, filed at the United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division, by Matt Dinerstein in behalf of the affected patients, is seeking for appropriate damages and an injunction to halt the continued operations of the project between Google and the University of Chicago.

University of Chicago shared EHR to Google

The lawsuit alleges that the University of Chicago lends its patient database to a Google project that uses data from patients’ electronic medical records to try to make better predictions and advance artificial intelligence in medicine.

In the process, the university shared the sensitive medical information of patients without their consent to a third party. This data, the lawsuit said, is not “just run-of-the-mill like credit card numbers, usernames, and passwords, or even social security numbers, which nowadays seem to be the subject of daily hacks; rather, the personal medical information obtained by Google is the most sensitive and intimate information in an individual’s life, and its unauthorized disclosure is far more damaging to an individual’s privacy.”

“Beginning in 2017, Google set in motion a plan to make its most significant play in the healthcare space. This plan had two key components: (1) obtain the Electronic Health Record (“EHR”) of nearly every patient from the University of Chicago Medical Center from 2009 to 2016; and (2) file a patent for its own proprietary and commercial EHR system that wouldn’t be published until well after it had obtained hundreds of thousands of EHRs from the University,” reads the 43-page court document obtained by Z6Mag.

The EHR included data of patients such as person’s height, weight, and vital signs, and other highly sensitive and confidential information like whether they suffer from diseases like AIDS, cancer, sickle cell, depression, sarcoidosis, or diabetes, or if they went through a medical procedure like an abortion, transplant, or mastectomy.

“In short, EHRs are the most personal and sensitive information that exists about a person,” the lawsuit said.

The court filing alleges that the University of Chicago Medical Center shared the data despite its obligation to safeguard the confidential health-related data of its patients. It also promised in its admission form that the hospital would not disclose any information to third-parties for commercial purposes.

Furthermore, the university also failed to notify its patients, not asked consent, before turning over their confidential medical records to Google.

“The University provided Google a partner willing to turn over the information that it desperately needed. Indeed, the University—seeking not much more than notoriety for its collaboration with Google in the development of healthcare products—was happy to turn over the confidential, highly sensitive and HIPAA-protected records of every patient who walked, through its doors between 2009 and 2016. Ultimately, by getting the University to turn over these records, Google quietly pulled off a feat that other tech giants (like Facebook) have had to abandon under mounting public pressure for other gross privacy violations,” reads the document.

The University of Chicago covered up the data breach

To make matters worse, the class-action alleges that the University is also involved in covering up the fact to “avoid public backlash.”

“The cover-up is particularly egregious because the University had a legal duty to inform its patients and the authorities of the unauthorized transfer of their medical records to Google. While this type of public misinformation campaign may be expected from a tech company that has been known to play fast and loose with the information of its customers, the fact that a prominent institution like The University of Chicago would act in such a way is truly stunning,” it added.

Dinerstein and the class is suing Google and University of Chicago Medical center for violations of The Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act, 815 ILCS 505 (“ICFA”), which protects both consumers and competitors by promoting fair competition in commercial markets for goods and services.

The plaintiff also wants the involved entities to be liable for breach of and tortious interference with contract, intrusion upon seclusion, and unjust enrichment.

A consumer tech and cybersecurity journalist who does content marketing while daydreaming about having unlimited coffee for life and getting a pet llama. I also own a cybersecurity blog called Zero Day.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Technology

Facebook May Be Tracking Your Online Photos Too

While no active hacking is happening, security experts believe that the discovery carries heavy implications.

Published

on

Photo by Glen Carrie on Unsplash

It appears that Facebook is not only tracking people’s porn-watching behavior online but also the photos they download. A researcher has found Facebook trackers in several images that he downloaded that could potentially point out to one thing: Facebook is tracking everyone.

But this shouldn’t surprise anyone. Facebook isn’t necessarily the supreme authority in data safety and cybersecurity. But the discovery made by Edin Jusupovic proves that Facebook’s tracking mission does not end in its platform.

On Twitter, Jusupovic said that Facebook has embedded “hidden tracking codes” in photos that people download. He noticed a structural abnormality when looking at a hex dump of an image file from an unknown origin only to discover it contained a special IPTC instruction.

IPTC (International Press Telecommunications Council) is an organization that sets publishing standards, including image metadata.

According to the researcher, what he found, where facebook secretly embeds tracking codes in photos only, was ““shocking level of tracking,” adding that “the take from this is that they can potentially track photos outside of their own platform with a disturbing level of precision about who originally uploaded the photo (and probably so much more).”

Yesterday, Z6Mag published a report that a group of researchers has found hidden tracking codes in different porn sites online that can be traced back to Facebook, Google, and Oracle. Researchers from Microsoft, Carnegie Mellon, and the University of Pennsylvania scanned 22,484 porn sites and found that 93% of the sade porn sites include hidden codes from the three tech giants.

Related: Study Finds Google And Facebook Trackers In Porn Sites

“Our analysis of 22,484 pornography websites indicated that 93% leak user data to a third party. Tracking on these sites are highly concentrated by a handful of major companies, which we identify. We successfully extracted privacy policies for 3,856 sites, 17% of the total. The policies were written such that one might need a two-year college education to understand them. Our content analysis of the sample’s domains indicated 44.97% of them expose or suggest a specific gender/sexual identity or interest likely to be linked to the user,” the study’s abstract stated.

Jusopovic’s finding “IPTC special instructions” simply refers to a special kind of coded watermark that Facebook adds to tag the image in its own coding. These are where the “tracking” comes into the picture – those tags can be read later. Meaning, Facebook will now how the data of people who had downloaded the image, reuploaded it, and all other information that can be linked to the movement of the image across the internet.

What does it imply?

Adding coded watermarks to images is not new tho. It can be used by the company in arbitrating copyrights claims, or providing better user service, and even in targeting the right target market for advertising. However, as Jusopovic states, what he found was a “shocking level of tracking.”

According to one analyst, the metadata has been added since 2016 and “contains an IPTC block with an ‘Original Transmission Reference’ field that contains some kind of text-encoded sequence. This coding method lets Facebook “know it has seen the image before when it gets uploaded again,” explained a user on Reddit. “It is yet another way to learn associations between people. Person 1 uploaded a bunch of the same photos Person 2 uploaded, let’s show them both all the same advertisements!”

But it needs to be clarified that there is no active tracking that it is happening. With “tracking,” Jusopovic means that Facebook and other people with the right tools can access all the metadata in a photo including the crumbles it picks up as it moves from one platform to another. However, this too carries a lot of security of implications.

“Hidden data can be predictably transmitted through social network images with high-fidelity – and AI can hide that data in plain sight, at large-scale, and beyond human visual discernment, making steganalysis and other countermeasures difficult,” Zack Allen from ZeroFOX.

Nonetheless, the discovery of Jusopovic is proof that Facebook is yet to make do with its promises to protect people’s data as well as make sure that people are aware of what happens to their data. This promise follows the high-profile case involving Facebook and Cambridge Analytica, where the social media giant was slapped with a five-billion fine by the FTC.

Continue Reading

Technology

Educational Institutions And Services Are Targets Of Recent Data Breaches

Two separate data breach have affected 62 US colleges and more than 7 million users of the K12.com, with vulnerabilites already exploited by hackers.

Published

on

Photo by Element5 Digital on Unsplash

Education institutions have been victims of two separate data breaches and hacker attacks that have exposed millions of student data to the prying eyes in the wild.

For one of the exposure, more than 62 US colleges have been breached by a hacker that has exploited a vulnerability in an enterprise resource planning (ERP) web app; the U.S. Education Department confirmed this week.

Ellucian Banner Web Tailor, a module of the Ellucian Banner ERP, which allows universities to customize and design their hope-page websites and online applications, has had a vulnerability that was exploited by a hacker who made fake user profiles that are “almost immediately for criminal activity.”

Banner Web Tailor is a web tool, made for higher education institutions, that provides registration, curriculum management, advising, administration, and reporting functionality. Students can access and change their registration, graduation, and financial aid information. It is also used by professors and teachers to input grades which the students can then view online. It is used by hundreds of institutions, many of which have opted to use the Single Sign-on Manager to participate in CAS- and SAML-based single sign-on services.

Joshua Mulliken, a cybersecurity researcher discovered a vulnerability in the authentication mechanism used by the two modules earlier this year. This vulnerability allowed a hacker to hijack students’ web-sessions and take over their accounts. Ellucian fixed the vulnerability in May, and public disclosure was published, by both the researcher and NIST.

“An improper authentication vulnerability (CWE-287) was identified in Banner Web Tailor and Banner Enterprise Identity Services. This vulnerability is produced when SSO Manager is used as the authentication mechanism for Web Tailor, where this could lead to information disclosure and loss of data integrity for the impacted user(s). The vendor has verified the vulnerability and produced a patch that is now available. For more information, see the postings on Ellucian Communities,” reads the public disclosure of the vulnerability.

According to the announcement made by the US Education Department, hackers have already started exploiting the said vulnerability. “The Department has identified 62 colleges or universities that have been affected by the exploitation of this vulnerability,” officials said.

We have also recently received information that indicates criminal elements have been actively scanning the internet looking for institutions to victimize through this vulnerability and developing lists of institutions for targeting with this exploitation.”

The attackers, as said by the officials for the Education Department, “leverage scripts in the admissions or enrollment section of the affected Banner system to create multiple student accounts.” One victim reported that the attackers created thousands of fake accounts over days, with around 600 accounts created within 24 hours.

K12.com exposes users’ data

Meanwhile, a recent data breach involving K12.com has compromised more than seven million students’ data who use one of the company’s programs, leaving the data accessible to anyone online.

In June 25, 2019, Comparitech and security researcher Bob Diachenko uncovered the exposure when they found an unprotected MongoDB out in the open as they scan for unsecured databases.

The exposure affected K12.com’s A+nyWhere Learning System (A+LS), which is used by more than 1,100 school districts. The database has 6,988,504 records containing students’ data. The information held within each file included:

  • Primary personal email address
  • Full name
  • Gender
  • Age
  • Birthdate
  • School name
  • Authentication keys for accessing ALS accounts and presentations
  • Other internal data

“In this instance, an old version of MongoDB (2.6.4) was being utilized. This version of the database hasn’t been supported since October 2016. What’s more, the Remote Desktop Protocol (RDP) was enabled but not secured. As a result, the database was indexed by both the Shodan and BinaryEdge search engines. This means the records contained in the database were visible to the public,” said the researchers.

The researchers were able to reach out to K12.com, and a representative from the company said: “K12 takes data security very seriously. Whenever we are advised of a potential security issue, we investigate the problem immediately and take the appropriate actions to remedy the situation.”

While the danger that comes from the exposed data was not as huge as the first data breach involving the world’s educational system, the researchers said that it carries with it some implications.

“While the leak of this information isn’t as bad as, for example, the exposure of financial data or Social Security numbers, it does have its implications. These pieces of information can be used to target individual students in spear phishing and account takeover fraud. Having their school name made public could potentially put students at risk of physical harm,” they said.

Continue Reading

Technology

Morpheus Chip Is Almost Impossible To Hack Says Researchers

Much like the Greek god, Morpheus chip is a hacker’s nightmare.

Published

on

"Memory Chip - Intel, 1702A-6, 1970s" by Matilda Vaughan is licensed under CC BY 4.0

As cyber criminals up their game in terms of deriving different sophisticated techniques to compromise systems, steal funds, and take over identities, a group of researchers has developed what some media outlets called unhackable chip that is designed to confuse hackers and prevent them from infiltrating systems at the microprocessor level.

Researchers from the University of Michigan call it “Morpheus,” and it said to be “vulnerability tolerant” as it blocks potential attacks by confusing hackers and making it difficult for them to hack at the chip level.

Morpheus is backed by the famous US Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) and is a new chip architecture that bridges the gap between program and machine-level semantics making a system’s firewall impenetrable.

“Attacks often succeed by abusing the gap between program and machine-level semantics– for example, by locating a sensitive pointer, exploiting a bug to overwrite this sensitive data, and hijacking the victim program’s execution,” reads the study’s abstract.

Most common attacks today use malware to trick systems into misusing basic programming possibilities such as permissions and code injection, or into manipulating unusual states.

“In this work, we take secure system design on the offensive by continuously obfuscating information that attackers need, but normal programs do not use, such as [the] representation of code and pointers or the exact location of code and data,” the researchers added.

Just like the Greek god, Morpheus can manipulate program values

According to the developers of the Morpheus, the new chip architecture combines two powerful protections: ensembles of moving target defenses and churn.

The first layer of protection which is ensembling moving target defenses, the chip architecture randomizes key program values (e.g., relocating pointers and encrypting code and pointers) “which forces attackers to probe the system before an attack extensively.”

This means that much like Morpheus, the Greek god of sleep, the chip architecture can make fundamental program values (dreams) to shapeshift to make it harder for future hackers to distinguish them and exploit their vulnerabilities.

The second layer of protection brought by the new chip architecture is the churn, which transparently re-randomizes program values running underneath the system. “With frequent churn, systems quickly become impractically difficult to penetrate,” they said.

Furthermore, Morpheus is also designed to perform both the protection processes, re-randomizing program values every 50 milliseconds, which is faster than any hacker can catch up with, making it highly difficult to locate.

“Each moving target defense in Morpheus uses hardware support to individually offer more randomness at a lower cost than previous techniques. When ensembled with churn, Morpheus defenses offer strong protection against control-flow attacks, with our security testing and performance studies revealing:

  • high-coverage protection for a broad array of control-flow attacks, including protections for advanced attacks and an attack disclosed after the design of Morpheus, and
  • negligible performance impacts (1%) with churn periods up to 50 ms, which our study estimates to be at least 5000x faster than the time necessary to possibly penetrate Morpheus,” they wrote in their study.

One of the proponents of the study explained how the Morpheus chip works using analogies he derived from solving the Rubik’s cube puzzle.

“Imagine trying to solve a Rubik’s Cube that rearranges itself every time you blink. That’s what hackers are up against with Morpheus. It makes the computer an unsolvable puzzle,” University of Michigan’s Todd Austin explains to journalists.

The researchers said that another way of understanding how Morpheus works is that it is a low-level version of a standard protection technique called Address Space Layout Randomisation (ASLR).

Nonetheless, the researchers said that Morpheus chip architecture is not “unhackable.” Other techniques could fight off its protective mechanisms as it does not address all forms of attack. However, the innovation will reduce the attack surface at the very least.

“Looking ahead, we see great potential for EMTD technologies,” the researchers said. “Beyond control-flow attacks, we envision that a similar approach could be adopted to protect against side-channel attacks, timing attacks, Rowhammer attacks, and even cache attacks. To address each of these additional challenges, we will explore what assets the attacker needs and then develop efficient mechanisms to boost uncertainty and stifle attacks,” they added.

Continue Reading

Trending